Europeans on the Move—to Germany

What Europe should take from its latest migration trends

21/08/2012 | by Steven Hill

Category: Migration, Security, Germany, Central Europe, Europe

Recent statistics are showing that workers from crisis-stricken countries on Europe's periphery are making their way in greater numbers to more stable Germany. But the increasing labor migration doesn't necessarily need to be cause for alarm.

flickr user MPD01605, CC BY

Recent figures from the German Federal Employment Agency reveal that the number of Greeks working in Germany increased by 9.8 percent in one year, and the number of Spaniards by 11.5 percent. Portuguese and Italian workers also made a beeline for Germany. Overall, these four countries sent over 450,000 workers, a 6.5 percent increase, to Germany over the past year.

The internal migration trend of European workers has inspired a considerable amount of debate and anxious handwringing. I recall a recent conversation with a German friend who was lamenting about all the young Germans who are moving out of Germany. So I asked her, "Where are they moving to?" When she said Austria and Switzerland, I couldn't help but laugh. That's like someone from California complaining that their young Californians are moving to the states of Oregon or Washington.

In the United States—which has for the most part constructed a successful economic, monetary and political union over the past two centuries—one would never hear someone say that a young Californian who picked up and moved to New York or Texas or Florida to get a job was somehow a failure of California, or even California’s loss. Mostly because, over time, other young people from New York or Texas are going to move to California or Florida or elsewhere in the US. That's the type of natural ebb and flow of transmigration one should expect.

In fact, one of the criticisms of the European system has been that while capital, i.e. finance, corporations and banks, have become global companies and in that sense hyper “migratory,” workers remain stuck in place, rooted in the home soil (primarily due to reasons of language and culture, as well as the logistical challenges to relocation). This gives banks and corporations leverage over workers. So should we now lament an increase in labor migration?

I don't think so. In fact, I actually view the emigration of Spaniards, Italians and Greeks as a positive, and something that Europe needs to get used to. Sure, to the extent that it represents a brain drain from these states, that is a downside. But Spain, Greece and Italy need to do more to attract businesses from other parts of Europe to relocate there, and with it will come those businesses' skills and expertise. If Europe is to have a dynamic continental economy, it really can't work any other way, can it?

And keep in mind, this is not the first time Europe has seen waves of mass emigration. In the 1960s, entire families from poorer, rural Spain left for the factories of northern Europe. In 1965, 80,000 people emigrated and in 1969, 100,000 emigrated, mostly to Europe.

This is part of the "new normal," and how a European “Union” is supposed to work.

STEVEN HILL ( is the author of Europe's Promise: Why the European Way is the Best Hope in an Insecure Age and 10 Steps to Repair American Democracy.



Most Read

Latest blog posts

  • Support For Ukrainian Unbraiding

    How Merkel went from hot to cold on Tymoshenko

    While Yulia Tymoshenko was imprisoned in Ukraine, Angela Merkel was her staunchest ally. But since her release, the relationship has cooled off dramatically. Berlin fears that Tymoshenko is turning into a fervently anti-Russian nationalist in order to win the presidential elections.

  • Paying the Gas Piper

    Former Soviet republics weakest link in EU energy security chain

    The Baltic states, overwhelmingly dependent upon Russian energy supplies, experience most directly the high costs of their neighbor's political pressure on the EU. Could diversification including renewables provide these countries some relief?

  • Greening the Heartlands of Coal in Europe

    New Böll Foundation report sheds light on renewables in Central Europe

    Germany's Energiewende has also impacted Poland and the Czech Republic, but these effects are rarely discussed or well-understood by German lawmakers. EU-wide energy policies are needed in order to ensure that Germany's transition to renewables is permanent, sustainable, and fair to its neighbors.